The quotes in the mirrors
Historical context for the women’s conversations
Although the women’s conservations in the Drawing Room have been imagined based on historical evidence, their dialogue contains real excerpts from archival sources. These quotes also appear on the Drawing Room mirrors. Keep reading to learn about the original quotes and the women who authored them.
It is better to have an object of conversation than to indulge in vapid talk.
Florence Howe Hall
This quote comes from writer, critic, and suffrage activist Florence Howe Hall. In a 1905 Harper’s Bazaar article[1], she describes the increasing popularity of “special amusement,” like palm readers and orchestras, at Newport social events. She argues these activities challenge perceptions of Newport’s “utter frivolity” and ends with the quote to reinforce her point.
A recent ball brought about the keenest social rivalry displayed by Newport social leaders.
The New York Times
This quote is a paraphrased excerpt from a New York Times article[2] recounting an incident between Mrs. Mamie Fish and Mrs. Alice Vanderbilt. Allegedly, the women competed bitterly to host the Prince of Sweden during his 1907 visit to Newport. Social columnists delighted in exaggerating the rivalries between elite women as though they were military commanders or battling monarchs.
...higher luxury which art and intelligence and delicate appreciation can alone bring.
Mary Elizabeth Wilson Sherwood
This abbreviated quote comes from Manners and Social Usages, an 1897 etiquette manual by M.E.W. Sherwood[3]. The original full-length quote challenges the idea that women, including those who enjoy material luxuries, have no need for intellectual stimulation: “Even the most idle woman desires that higher luxury which art and intelligence and delicate appreciation can alone bring.”
Etiquette is the machinery of society.
Abby Buchanan Longstreet
This quote comes from Abby Buchanan Longstreet’s Social Etiquette of New York[4], which was published in 1891. In the opening chapter, “The Value of Etiquette,” Longstreet enumerates the social uses of good manners. She argues that etiquette is essential to a well-functioning society and personal happiness.
Equal suffrage could give American women a position of increased dignity and influence.
Julia Ward Howe
Julia Ward Howe was an author, poet, abolitionist, and suffragist. She also famously wrote the lyrics to the “Battle Hymn of the Republic” (1861).
In 1909, Howe published an article[5] laying out her case for women’s suffrage. The above quote constitutes her first point. She supports it with commentary from women who have the right to vote in Colorado, New Zealand, and Australia. They are united in their observation that enfranchised women enjoy greater respect from men and society.
Primary sources cited
- Florence Howe Hall, “Changes in Newport Life and Forms of Entertainment,” Harper's Bazaar 39, 11 (November 1905), 1033.
- “Mrs. Fish’s Triumph in Social Rivalry,” The New York Times, August 23, 1907, 1.
- Mary Elizabeth Wilson Sherwood, Manners and Social Usages (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1897), 246.
- Abby Buchanan Longstreet, Social etiquette of New York (New York: D. Appleton & Co., 1891), 8.
- Julia Ward Howe, "Woman and the Suffrage: The Case for Woman Suffrage," The American Journal of Nursing 9, no 8 (May 1909): 560.