Skip to main content

A second strike in July

The discontent continues

Three weeks after the June strike, another walkout occurred at The Elms. This time, the new butler, Robert Mitchell, and four of his staff quit after clashing with Herminie’s pet monkeys and the housekeeper. In interviews with the newspapers, Mitchell complained that the monkeys “were treated better than the servants and were stuck up and saucy.”

No respectable butler would stand being chased around the table by pet monkeys while serving dinner... that's why I struck. [1]

Robert Mitchell

Mitchell also claimed his “main trouble” was the housekeeper, whom he called “Miss Bull”—likely a derogatory nickname. Specifically, Mitchell felt she had “usurped” his rights by taking control of the pantry, typically the butler’s domain.

Article from The Journal  (Meridien, CT), July 12, 1902.[2]

Beyond The Elms, ten of Pembroke Jones’ staff left their posts in early July. The next day, three of George D. Widener’s staff followed suit. In response, one paper remarked that “strike fever is spreading.”

All the neighbors in Newport are talking about the servant problem and wondering what the trouble will lead to.[3]

Reading Times

At the same time, the wave of labor activism sweeping the nation that summer may have also influenced the Newport strikes. Given that only secondhand accounts of the strikes exist, it’s difficult to confirm specific details about the summer’s events.

Primary sources cited

  1. “Servants Struck,” The Jackson Daily News, July 16, 1902, p 5.
  2. “Servants’ Strike,” The Journal, Meridien, July 12, 1902, p.7.

  3. George D. Widener’s Newport Help Strike. Reading Times. 7/12/1902. p5.